Sept 26, 2022
Hornbuckle prevails in Public Records Act case to obtain nursing home records
Nursing homes are extensively regulated to ensure resident safety, and those regulations are enforced in the nursing home survey process. The surveyors are employed by the Washington State Department of Social and Health Services (“DSHS”). The surveyors gather medical records and interview facility employees following an allegation of poor care or neglect of a resident. The notes and records gathered are referred to as the surveyor’s “working papers.” These records often contain critical information in lawsuits against nursing homes alleging abuse or neglect.
DSHS has long withheld working papers in response to requests under the Washington State Public Records Act and redacts the records that they do produce. I believe that they should disclose the working papers and filed a lawsuit to force them to do so.
In the trial court, DSHS relied on the “Touhy” regulations as its basis for withholding the working papers, 45 CFR § 2.1, claiming that the surveyor who created the working papers was an employee of the federal government. Federal employees are not subject to the state Public Records Act. DSHS also stipulated that the surveyor was not an employee of the federal government. The trial court avoided the issue of whether the surveyor was a federal employee by correctly noting that 45 CFR § 2 only applied to “proceedings,” and a state records request was not a proceeding. The trial court ruled in my favor and ordered disclosure of the working papers.
DSHS appealed, resulting in the attached opinion. The court of appeals also avoided the question of whether a state surveyor is a federal “employee,” which was an important question I had hoped to get addressed in the lawsuit. But I prevailed in the lawsuit on a narrow ground that the federal government’s own regulations clearly allowed for state procedures such as the Public Records Act to apply to the request for the working papers.
Here is a link to the opinion in Hornbuckle v. Washington State Department of Social and Health Services, Cause No. 82675-1-I: https://www.courts.wa.gov/opinions/pdf/826751.pdf
Stephen Hornbuckle of The Hornbuckle Firm has solid experience in handling cases involving nursing home abuse and neglect, with many successful verdicts and settlements to show for it. He and his associates are happy to discuss your case with you. Contact us at (425) 679-0742 to schedule an appointment.
DO I HAVE A CASE?
the initial consultation is free
Please call (425) 679-0742 or contact The Hornbuckle Firm today to schedule your free nursing home abuse and neglect consultation. The firm has litigated cases in Washington, Tennessee, and Texas. We accept cases from all states across the country.
WHAT OTHERS ARE SAYING ABOUT US:
He appears to be committed to his clients and ably represents them, even when he is at risk of not getting compensated for his time and effort due to difficulties in the case.Fellow Attorney
Stephen is an excellent lawyer. I received one of my highest jury verdicts with him as my co-counsel. I am very impressed with his abilities.Fellow Attorney
Highly competent attorney & law firm.A Judge
I've known Stephen since law school. He is a powerful thinker and excellent attorney.Government Counsel